American families' plight: Lives
structured to a fault
By Joseph B. Verrengia: The Associated Press
March 20, 2005
Kim Zeiss, organizes the family schedule on her Palm Pilot with
the help of her husband, Gary, as their son, Jake, 9, watches while
they wait for their daughter, Madison, 10, at the Los Angeles
International Fencing Center in West Los Angeles, Calif.
Sociology: The intimate moments that once bonded parents and children
are disappearing amid job demands and nonstop activities, as shown in a
video project by researchers and a firsthand account by the Associated
Press
LOS ANGELES — Jake Zeiss bolts from his west L.A. bungalow
before 8 a.m., red hair damp and shirttail flapping.
Later, after seven hours of back-to-back meetings, he volleys
for an hour with his tennis pro. Still perspiring, he slides back into
his vehicle, gobbles a nutrition bar and does paperwork on a lap desk
while his chauffeur burrows through the nation's worst rush-hour
traffic.
Jake Zeiss is 9 years old. His paperwork is multiplication
tables.
The Zeiss family is late for hockey practice. After that, it's
fencing lessons for Madison, Jake's 10-year-old sister. Their father,
Gary, a 47-year-old attorney, will meet them at the gym — hopefully by
8 p.m.
Jake and Madison's mom, Kim Zeiss, has transformed her vehicle
into a rolling Wal-Mart, with cases of snacks and drinks buried beneath
backpacks and sports equipment.
The Zeiss family might be insanely busy. But they are not alone.
Scientists at UCLA have spent the past four years observing 32
Los Angeles families in a study of how working America somehow gets it
done. Day after day.
For a week, scientists using digital video cameras recorded the
Zeisses' every move. Back in the lab, the researchers analyzed their
behavior — frame by frame — intent on seeing them with a dispassionate
eye.
Archaeologists sifted through the family's belongings, down to
the stray sock behind the dryer and the cans of tuna in the pantry.
Psychologists required everyone but the family dog Ozzie to spit
into test tubes several times a day. The vials were frozen and shipped
to a Pennsylvania lab where technicians measured the rise and fall of
stress hormones in saliva.
The UCLA Center on Everyday Lives of Families is one of six
long-term projects sponsored by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation
examining the intersection between family life and work.
At UCLA, a team of 21 researchers has completed the $3.6 million
data-collection phase. A second phase will be devoted to analysis and,
researchers hope, influencing federal policy on family issues.
Working moms
Already, trends are emerging from their observations, and they
appear to be related to the biggest change in family dynamics since Kim
and Gary Zeiss were kids themselves:
Mothers working outside the home.
It's a poorly understood seismic shift in both the nation's
economy and daily life. For some families in the study, it allows them
to own a bigger house, drive better cars and take nicer vacations.
For many more families in the study, two paychecks are necessary
to put food on the table.
Researchers say now there are three jobs in the American family
— two careers plus parenting — and only two people to accomplish them.
In short, home life is beginning to imitate the downsized
American office.
It means parents and children live virtually apart at least five
days a week. They reunite for a few hours at night, sleep and separate
again the next morning. In this study, at least one parent was likely
to be up and gone before the children awoke.
When they are together, today's families tend to stay in motion
with lessons, classes and games. Or, they go shopping.
UCLA researchers say that, for the most part, husbands in their
study haven't cut back on their work. Some, like Gary Zeiss, work from
home occasionally. Others help out with chores a little more.
Mothers in the UCLA study still bear the key household and
child-rearing responsibilities, even while working full time.
Researchers contend this appears to erode families from within.
What's falling by the wayside?
Playtime. Conversation. Courtesy. Intimacy.
And guess who is driving the minivan now? Researchers say
parents effectively have relinquished the steering wheel to their
children. That's because most family decisions and purchases are geared
toward the kids' activities.
Whether these highly programmed kids will grow up to become
competent and compassionate adults is an open question for many
scientists.
The study's requirements were straightforward: Find households
with two parents who work outside the home, pay a mortgage and have two
or three school-aged children.
The 32 families were paid $1,000 each to participate. Most
responded to ads in neighborhood newspapers.
The families reflect L.A.'s ethnic stew: Anglo, black, Hispanic,
Vietnamese, Indian and others. Two families had same-sex parents. They
lived all over greater Los Angeles, from the ranch house subdivisions
of the San Fernando Valley to the gang-plagued streets of Compton.
Some facts of L.A. life, like traffic, could not be avoided. Yet
the scientists believe they structured the study so it examined the
interior factors of everyday life that are just as true elsewhere.
By using cameras, the scientists documented the families' real
reactions and conversations as the day unfolded.
Each family was observed over a week's time. Researchers would
stick with the families from the morning's first pot of coffee to
bedtime. They followed a simple rule: Knock first.
Their method invites comparisons to the landmark 1973 PBS series
that documented the lives of the Loud family, from dance recitals to a
gay son to the parents' divorce.
But this is Ph.D.-style reality TV. It's not a portrait of a
single family.
In 1,600 hours of digital video, scientists captured moments of
unfiltered joy — but also of sorrow, anger and frustration.
The UCLA study isn't ranking families from best to worst.
Instead, scientists are asking how families are coping.
In a word, barely.
For the study's director, Elinor Ochs, a linguistic
anthropologist, the most worrisome trend is how indifferently people
treat each other, especially when they reunite at the day's end.
With a mouse click, she summons footage from the project's vast
archive. Some of it is hard to watch.
• A man walks into the bedroom after work as his wife folds laundry.
There is no kiss, or even a hello. Instead, they resume their breakfast
argument virtually in midsentence about who left food on the counter to
spoil. (He did.)
• An executive mother wears a pained smile as her daughter refuses to
meet her gaze. Finally, the embarrassed nanny prompts the girl to speak
while buttoning the girl's pajamas.
• A big bear of a man squeezes into his cramped home office where his
son is playing a computer game with two pals. He rubs his son's head,
but the boy doesn't blink. As the father shuffles out, the son gestures
toward the computer and mutters, "I thought you were going to fix
this."
Ochs says other human cultures — even other species like wolves
— greet each other in elaborate ways that reinforce social bonds.
In her view, the chilly exchanges repeated in so many of the
study's households suggest something has gone awry.
"Returning home at the end of the day is one of the most
delicate and vulnerable moments in life," Ochs said. "Everywhere in the
world, in all societies, there is some kind of greeting.
"But here, the kids aren't greeting the parents and the parents
are allowing it to go on," Ochs said. "They are tiptoeing around their
children."
The Zeiss family, however, is positively tribal with hugs and
shouts. Their packed schedule just means they reunite in the car or
parking lots.
Madison catches up on her homework as she and brother Jake
travel to Jake's hockey practice. "Fortunately, the kids don't get car
sick," their mom quips as she drives the minivan.
After a 40-minute drive to the ice rink, Madison races to the
snack bar while Jake drags his hockey equipment into a musky locker
room.
He plays for the Junior Kings, an all-star team affiliated with
the city's NHL franchise. Elbow to elbow, Kim and 20 other mothers
strip their sons down to their Spiderman undies and strap on pads the
size of sofa cushions. After double-knotting Jake's skate laces, she
slaps his helmet and he waddles out toward the ice.
"When they turn 10, they dress themselves and moms can't come
in," she says, squatting on a duffel bag to catch her breath. "None of
us want to see that day. What else am I going to do — sleep?"
No time-outs
Kim's remark raises a second trend emerging from the UCLA data —
little time for dreaming.
Ochs laments how few people have any unstructured time. In just
one of the 32 families did the father — a freelance film animator —
make a habit of taking an evening stroll with his son and daughter.
Hand in hand, they dodged vacant lots and broken glass in Culver City
while chasing fireflies and making up stories.
Similar Sloan-funded studies launched in Italy and Sweden hint
that families in those countries stay home more. The American kids
spend less time at home and virtually no time in the yard. Play time
tends to be organized and supervised by adults.
Kim and Gary Zeiss are keeping their children busy by design.
They believe it's a key to being a successful adult in a culture that
rewards multitaskers.
A typical Monday for the Zeiss family has four or five
after-school events. They are in constant touch by cellphone,
Blackberry and pager.
It's very different from how they were raised in Miami in the
1970s. Gary wasn't allowed to play football; his parents feared for his
safety, but he remembers feeling unchallenged.
Now he is reviving his interest in fencing, which he shares with
Madison, who's ranked No. 5 nationally in her age group. Academically,
she's near the top of her middle school, too.
"The kids are doing well," he says. "They are getting good
grades. They're not obese. At the end of the day, this is good for
them."
Kim's mother was divorced, and Kim spent afternoons alone
watching TV and doing homework. Some days she would ride her bicycle 15
miles to the beach.
She pauses, bothered by the memory. Nothing bad ever happened,
but it could have.
Now 43, she worked as a television producer at MTV and ESPN
until Jake was 2. Recently she became an administrator at Madison's
school.
Drowning in trappings
With all the scheduling and management, family life begins to
resemble running a small business. That means requisitioning materials
and supplies, which invariably leads to a third hallmark of the study:
clutter.
Archaeologist Jeanne Arnold planned to treat each house in the
study like a dig site, cataloging and mapping family belongings as
artifacts. But there was too much stuff. Instead, her staff took
photographs. Thousands of them.
For Arnold, who is accustomed to examining bits of bone and
pottery, modern households are overwhelming. How much stuff do people
own? So much that only two families have room to park their cars in the
garage.
By Arnold's rough estimate, the typical American family owns
more than most Egyptian pharaohs, who were buried with their treasures
for the journey to the afterworld.
Little of today's clutter would be mistaken for King Tut's gold.
It's piles of leftovers — clothing draped over old computers that are
balancing on boxes of forgotten toys resting on top of old furniture.
The world has never seen consumption on this scale, Arnold says.
"And every week we see more stuff arriving. People can't stop."
Face time
Researchers say schedules and clutter butt heads to create the
fourth family trend: flux.
Using computers, scientists mapped the location of each family
member throughout the home every 10 minutes. Originally, they planned
to conduct this electronic roll call every 20 or 30 minutes. But they
found themselves chasing their subjects from room to room as they
orbited one another, hardly pausing.
Ochs says families gathered in the same room just 16 percent of
the time. In five homes, the entire family was never in the same room
while scientists were observing. Not once.
For parents, togetherness is even tougher to come by. In only
six families did the parents spend more than 10 percent of their waking
hours in the same room without a child present.
"People just don't come together very frequently in our
society," Ochs said. "They might say they want community, but they
don't seek it."
The Zeiss family congregates for dinner, but late.
Gary and Madison don't return from fencing practice until 10:20
p.m. For the past hour, Jake has been practicing his drums for
Tuesday's music lesson.
Kim spoons chili from the crock pot and serves salad and mashed
sweet potato. The television is off.
Conversation ping-pongs. Upcoming birthday parties. Jury duty.
Jake's favorite rock group, Linkin Park, is signing CDs at Barnes &
Noble on Friday. Can he leave school early? Madison has a vocabulary
test in the morning.
Jake drops his spoon and starts rubbing his eyes. Time for
pajamas. It's 10:56 p.m.
Gary and Kim smile across the table. It's their first time alone
since the alarm clock buzzed 17 hours ago.
Kim stares at a spoonful of cold sweet potatoes, then eats it
with a shrug and stretches back in her chair.
"My feet are up," she announces to the ceiling. "We'll do it all
again tomorrow."
Seven hours from now.
Scary reality
One of over 300 articles