A man whose ideal weight is 170 pounds but
who weighs 250 pounds is carrying a substantial amount of fat in which the
virus may “hang out,” replicate and trigger a destructive immune system
response, Dr. David Kass, a professor of cardiology at Johns Hopkins.
By Roni
Caryn Rabin
The
New York Times
Dec.
8, 2021
From the start of the pandemic, the
coronavirus seemed to target people carrying extra pounds. Patients who were
overweight or obese were more likely to develop severe Covid-19 and more likely
to die.
Though these patients often have health
conditions like diabetes that compound their risk, scientists have become
increasingly convinced that their vulnerability has something to do with
obesity itself.
Now researchers have found that the
coronavirus infects both fat cells and certain immune cells within body fat,
prompting a damaging defensive response in the body.
“The bottom line is, ‘Oh my god, indeed, the
virus can infect fat cells directly,’” said Dr. Philipp Scherer, a scientist
who studies fat cells at UT Southwestern Medical Center in Dallas, who was not
involved in the research.
“Whatever happens in fat doesn’t stay in
fat,” he added. “It affects the neighboring tissues as well.”
The research has not yet been
peer-reviewed
or published in a scientific journal, but it was posted
online
(https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.10.24.465626v1)
in October. If the findings hold up, they may shed light not just on
why
patients with excess pounds are vulnerable to the virus, but also on
why
certain younger adults with no other risks become so ill.
The study’s senior authors, Dr. Tracey
McLaughlin and Dr. Catherine Blish of the Stanford University School of
Medicine, suggested the evidence could point to new Covid treatments that
target body fat.
“Maybe that’s the Achilles’ heel that the virus
utilizes to evade our protective immune responses — by hiding in this place,”
Dr. Vishwa Deep Dixit, a professor of comparative medicine and immunology at
Yale School of Medicine, said.
The finding is particularly relevant to the
United States, which has one of the highest rates of obesity in the world. Most
American adults are overweight, and 42 percent have obesity. Black, Hispanic,
Native American and Alaska Native people in the U.S. have higher obesity rates
than white adults and Asian Americans; they have also been disproportionately
affected by the pandemic, with death rates roughly double those of white
Americans.
“This could well be contributing to severe
disease,” Dr. Blish said. “We’re seeing the same inflammatory cytokines that I
see in the blood of the really sick patients being produced in response to
infection of those tissues.”
Body fat used to be thought of as inert, a
form of storage. But scientists now know that the tissue is biologically
active, producing hormones and immune-system proteins that act on other cells,
promoting a state of nagging low-grade inflammation even when there is no
infection.
Inflammation is the body’s response to an
invader, and sometimes it can be so vigorous that it is more harmful than the
infection that triggered it. “The more fat mass, and in particular visceral fat
mass, the worse your inflammatory response,” Dr. McLaughlin said, referring to
the abdominal fat that surrounds internal organs.
Fat tissue is composed mostly of fat cells,
or adipocytes. It also contains pre-adipocytes, which mature into fat cells,
and a variety of immune cells, including a type called adipose tissue
macrophages.
Dr. McLaughlin, Dr. Blish and their
colleagues at Stanford and in Germany and Switzerland carried out experiments
to see if fat tissue obtained from bariatric surgery patients could become
infected with the coronavirus, and tracked how various types of cells
responded.
The fat cells themselves could become
infected, the scientists found, yet did not become very inflamed. But certain
immune cells called macrophages also could be infected, and they developed a
robust inflammatory response.
Even stranger, the pre-adipocytes were not
infected, but contributed to the inflammatory response. (The scientists did not
examine whether particular variants were more destructive in this regard than
others.)
The research team also obtained fat tissue
from the bodies of European patients who had died of Covid and discovered the
coronavirus in fat near various organs.
The idea that adipose tissue might serve as a
reservoir for pathogens is not new, Dr. Dixit said. Body fat is known to harbor
a number of them, including H.I.V. and the influenza virus.
The coronavirus appears to be able to evade
the body fat’s immune defenses, which are limited and incapable of fighting it
effectively. And in people who are obese, there can be a lot of body fat.
A man whose ideal weight is 170 pounds but
who weighs 250 pounds is carrying a substantial amount of fat in which the
virus may “hang out,” replicate and trigger a destructive immune system
response, said Dr. David Kass, a professor of cardiology at Johns Hopkins.
“If you really are very obese, fat is the
biggest single organ in your body,” Dr. Kass said.
The coronavirus “can infect that tissue and
actually reside there,” he said. “Whether it hurts it, kills it or at best,
it’s a place to amplify itself — it doesn’t matter. It becomes kind of a
reservoir.”
As the inflammatory response snowballs,
cytokines trigger even more inflammation and the release of additional
cytokines. “It’s like a perfect storm,” he said.
Dr. Blish and her colleagues speculated that
infected body fat may even contribute to “long Covid,” a condition describing
troublesome symptoms like fatigue that persist for weeks or months after
recovery from an acute episode.
The data also suggest that Covid vaccines and
treatments may need to take into account the patient’s weight and fat stores.
“This paper is another wake-up call for the
medical profession and public health to look more deeply into the issues of
overweight and obese individuals, and the treatments and vaccines we’re giving
them,” said Barry Popkin, a professor of nutrition at University of North
Carolina at Chapel Hill, who has studied the heightened risk that Covid poses
to those with obesity.
“We keep documenting the risk they have, but
we still aren’t addressing it,” Dr. Popkin said.